The second one may work, as it seems to be adjustable. I don't know if the one on our trucks makes connection when it freezes or breaks connection when it detects freezing conditions, like ice. You'd want to know that to match it up exactly. I think setting that to turn off the compressor when your coils freeze may prevent you from getting the most benefit from cooling, because the compressor will be going off for longer periods to correct another issue. I found when I had my A/C system discharged in order to remove the hvac box, when they serviced it by pulling a good vacuum on the system, completely removing any moisture or air, as much as possible, then properly charged it up again, it cools tremendously better! I installed a heater control valve in the heater hoses to bypass the heater core when using A/C. Now I get 39 degree air out of the center vent on high recirculate! It never did that before. The condensate water pours out of the drain, and so far, it has not frozen. I think that the other fellow was right. They will freeze if over/ u nnder charged, especially undercharged. Hope you can find the prob... It may have to be evacuated and recharged as I did to mine.