Allow me to inject one further variable - the sauce. There are three; tomato based, mustard based and of course my favorite, vinegar based. Maurice Bessinger in South Carolina has made his 'Carolina Gold' a household staple (I order it by the case). The Williamson Bros. out of Marietta, GA have an unsurpassed tomato based sauce that Jennifer and I buy by the gallon from one of their restaurants in Douglasville, GA. It is fantastic!
And finally, Mr. Isaac Thomas and Mark Whitt in North Alabama delivered the coup de grace to the competition of good barbeque with their vinegar based sauce and lean pulled pork. They also serve their sandwiches with some cole slaw on top of the meat. I call it North Alabama style because in central Alabama it's just not served that way.
Now when you talk about chicken, Big Bob Gibson in Decatur makes his own white sauce (mayo and vinegar base) which will make you slap your mammy. And it would be neglectful of me to not mention their huge stuffed baked potato which has pulled pork, sour cream, butter, chives, cheddar cheeze and barbeque sauce.
Shorty out on Highway 20 west of Decatur at Hillsville made barbequed chicken an artform. I stopped by some time past and ordered two chicken plates to take home. Shorty said, "Mr. Ed, I sure am sorry but some fella from up North ate a plate and then bought every chicken I had, all forty-one, to take back home with him." LOL
I went back to Decatur to visit the kids some time ago and found that a tornado had cleaned off the concrete pad where Shorty had his restaurant. The world of culinary delights is a sadder place! I reckon Shorty went back to cotton farming and I left Hillsville with a stomach that was growling with disappointment.
Sorry about such a long epistle but you've got to realize that in this part of the country, we live to eat, not eat to live.
- Ed