There is another thread "VP44 failed today" where II addressed some of the things they see when they get failed VP44's. One of the thread responses is as follows:
The actual supply pressure should be 13. 5psi under load and 15-16psi would be ok at idle. 20=21psi will not make too much problem at idle. The problem with raising the pressure more and more is it changes the calibration of the pump. The biggest problem with excesive supply pressure is that the VP44 runs transfer pressure up to 100-120psi at full load. Any additional supply pressure increase will result in more transfer pressure over the 100-120psi. Since the VP44 is a rotory pump the head and rotor will seize or break due to too much hydraulic side loading. The seizure point from too much transfer pressure would be in the 150=160 range. Stuck trans. pressure regulator piston can cause high pressure and seizure. This is caused by contamination. If you want exact numbers for pressure I can get those while at work. If I can get off the phone. Thanks, Brady
This is where I get the impression that the closer to idle you are the more tolerant the deviation from 13. 5 psi is. The closer to 2K (cruise, or whatever rpm you normally are at most of the time) the less tolerant the deviation from 13. 5 psi (calibration psi) because of the hydraulic loading.
I think the transfer pressures are what run the things like the advance piston and hence the comment from AFarmer about too low a input pressure (10 psi or less) may not function the advance piston correctly. I can understand why it would not and can accept the concept of too low a input psi does not generate enough transfer pressure to cause the advance piston to function correctly.
I can also accept your comment about the narrower the range from idle to criuse rpm probably the better as it is closer to the calibration psi in all instances. However guys do have much much higher input psi's and seem to run that way for very very many 10,000's of miles to even 100,000's of miles.
I run a RASP and target 11 - 15 psi, trying to keep sufficient transfer presures for the "granny" way I drive (ie slow accelerations from idle) until I get the input psi up to at least 13. 5 (which is about 1200 rpm) and I know the transfer pressures are high enough to function the VP44.
I read that on the high side psi the limit is the tolerance of the transfer diaphram. It is designed to flex . 5mm (I think) and not distort it's seals. What this equates to in input pressures I do not know. The quote above implies there is not much allowed transfer pressures variation (100 - 120 psi), but what input deviation from 13. 5 input psi is that range of transfer pressures.
I sure hope some of the rebuilders will chime in and help us understand the psi relationships better.
Bob Weis