Skip, being ever curious and with nothing to do, I called Go Industries and they recommended the Rancher, saying it was a one piece, all welded unit, and therefore more substantial than the Big Tex which bolted together from three separate parts. Evidently their vat for applying chrome isn't large enough to accommodate the assembled unit. I am now leaning towards this particular grill guard, however, I wish I could justify the reinforced bumper combo that Cerb recommended. Sitting on the front porch with a $500 deductible makes my project justification look pretty lean, and my wife's argument a lot stronger. Ouch!
I hadn't considered a painted grill guard (and the Rancher only comes with a powder-coated finish) because I wanted stainless or at the least chrome, but a call to a friend who has a body shop told me that he would repaint the grill to match my truck for $100. Shopping around I found good prices at autoanything.com. (I apologize if I violated the forum rules with that. )
Ed