I doubt gears will make much of a difference, if you want the mileage you where getting with '01 you would need to turn down the power on your '04. 5 to match your '01. I have tried running tanks of fuel staying below a certain speed effectivly giving me the RPM I would have with taller gears, makes very little difference. I can run a tank staying at or below 65 on the highway, taking of slow from every light and get 17. 5MPG, or I can run 75 on the highway floor it from every stop light and get 16. 5MPG. I have the 4. 10s so the engine is spinnign pretty good at 75MPH. Power costs fuel even if you do not think you are using it, a motor that makes 325HP will use more fuel even when driven the same as a motor that makes 215HP.