Here I am

Dealing with a Donkey of a family member?

Attention: TDR Forum Junkies
To the point: Click this link and check out the Front Page News story(ies) where we are tracking the introduction of the 2025 Ram HD trucks.

Thanks, TDR Staff

Forrest Nearing

American Expedition Vehicles Open House!

Looking for opinions to support or tell me I was wrong.

My nephew (age 18) decided to get into my truck and then ran it into my garage in June.
He tried many times to tell me it rolled into the garage, but the driveway slopes away and after you read the damage will come to the same conclusion I did. He did this without my knowledge or my permission

He broke two studs in the garage wall, broke cabinets inside the garage hanging on the wall when he moved the wall. Obviously there was exterior cosmetic damage as well. Estimate from contractor who is a good friend of mine was 1600.
Truck needed bumper valiance, dent in fender fixed and both fenders realigned, bug deflector. Immediately had bad vibration which I assumed to be the carrier bearing. Something had to give when you put a 8K truck against a rigid object. Estimate from garage, also friend of mine, who BTW did free work for them when their car broke down at my mothers passing, was 2500.

The back story to my nephew is he was sent to NH from SC because he was involved in drugs, and was not going to graduate. My sister sent him to a family friend of hers to finish out school. He did, but had no plan for after HS.

Both he and my sister blew me off for over a week, after many attempts to speak with them about what plan they had, and what they intended to do. They left NH early to go back to SC without discussing anything but her ins company would cover it? I called mine, told them what happened. They told me sisters ins would not cover. SO I had to go through the BS with my sisters ins company finally getting a no.

They then accused me of inflating estimates, trying to steal from them. Insisting there was existing damage to truck and no way truck did that much damage to garage. Refused to pay full amount and tried to tell me how much they were paying.

At that point I told her I was done dealing with them, and going through my ins company. My ins company needed a police report. Police dept decided to charge him with theft due to damage amounts.

I have continued to receive scathing letters blaming everyone under the sun for what happened, blaming me for my nephews actions, and still accusing me of stealing from her. Everyone in my family is upset that there is now a NH warrant for my nephews arrest. She is extremely upset that spoke to anyone about it, including my father who attempted to loan her the money needed for the repairs, she refused it.

I have found out that the ins company is now going after all their money, and he still has the warrant.

I have ignored and refused to communicate with my sister because I know there is nothing I can say to get her to understand what happened, but it is eating a hole in me not blasting back.


Any thoughts on this from anyone?
 
Sounds like you did the right thing ! Trucks do not roll uphill, except under power.
Looks like another case of the boy being a product of the entitlement generation, and his momma again saying my baby could do no wrong. Even though she knows he has a bad track record.
Unfortunately as they say "You can pick your friends but not your relatives".
Hope you have good luck on getting reimbursed and your damage taken care of.
 
You can pick your nose, but can't pick your family. A family unit is essential, but who makes up that family is entirely up to you.

All too often people are afraid of tough love, and wind up coddling their children throughout their entire life. We have a 53 year old male in our family that has never been allowed to fail. He continues to lie, cheat and steal and I could care less if he get's ran over by a dump truck.

My side of the family wasn't all that great for me. Not bad people, just eclectic with money and jealousy issues. Fortunately, my wife's side and many, many good friends make up the difference and I have no shame in distancing myself from my blood relatives. Like I said, who makes up your family is entirely up to you.
 
Oh man, family stuff like that is hard to take. You did the right thing. Obviously, their version of reality is a big part of his problem.
 
Here's a little different opinion.
As I get older, I just remove myself from the BS if at all possible.
I have enough drama under my own roof.
Suck it up to a lesson learned. Eat it and move on.
jm.02
 
At minimum he should be responsible for your deductible on the claims with your insurance. I hate it and have been in similar situation where I was the one that screwed up and I have paid and learned lessons. The warrant is the hard part to swallow in this situation for sure.
 
I have been sent 1100 in the form of cashiers checks. I did not cash and I returned them. The amount was what she thought the estimate should be and I know if I cash them she will try to report me for insurance fraud. I assume she will tell the ins company she paid for the damages.

I will be out a little over 2K by the time everything is fixed with deductibles and not covered items? Gotta love insurance companies.

My sister's family is and will not be allowed at my house in the future. My father has just decided to not talk to me about it. He even demanded I retract my police statement and attempted to talk to the officer to stop the warrant.

He seemed to get it a little when I explained to him that I was the victim, but was being treated like the criminal. Had I done something like this at 18 my *** would have been handed to me by my father, he paid for damages, and I would have to settle with him. Seems strange he is supporting his daughter and not the guy to lives close and takes care of thigns for him.
 
Last edited:
Everyone making excuses for the little snot, sounds like some old family drama that I was involved in years ago. He Lied. Period. Refuses to man up and Mommy covers by blaming everyone and everything else instead.

Be done with them and move on.

Feel bad for your father in a way, most parents want their kids to get along but sadly that does not always work out.
 
I read a book a number of years ago called "Toxic People " or something like that. Anyway, it suggests walking away from situations to rid yourself of the prolonged agony that comes from issues with family. I've found that following that advice is extremely hard to do but benificial in the end.
 
I read a book a number of years ago called "Toxic People " or something like that. Anyway, it suggests walking away from situations to rid yourself of the prolonged agony that comes from issues with family. I've found that following that advice is extremely hard to do but benificial in the end.

It was that way for me. My wife and I moved about an hour away from my side of the family. It wasn't until then did I realize how cumbersome my side of the family was and how it affected us and our marriage. We habitually attended gatherings and such, but it was always so dramatic. Then we moved even further away and things just got better the less time we spent with them. I can honestly say that it's been uphill since and I think I'm a better person today. I do feel bad, but I feel even worse when I spend time with them.
 
Toxic people are a cancer of the soul.I've walked away from toxic people thrice now. When I walked away from Motorola in '00, when DHRA ended in '07, and when another venture failed in '14 (though I technically still own 12% of that one, it's effectively dead). And I, too, have a toxic sister with whom I am politely curt, but only when I have to be; otherwise, she's effectively non-existent.For your own sake, turn and walk away. It's the only way you can forgive them, put the experience on a storage shelf in your mind (where you don't have to look at it or reference it when you don't want to), and get back to living your life. (And this is probably as close as we dare to approach religion in this forum.)
 
Mark, you're singing one of my verses!
It's so friggin tough. You did the right thing by not taking the money. Pray for the kid and all involved, but you gotta protect yourself. Sounds like you're doing that. Nobody got physically hurt. This is the real important thing. Sounds like it could have been lots worse!
 
i feel your pain. it's tough for sure. i'm currently going through something similar.
my step dad passed away. and my biological dad and sister went in and removed all the valuable items in the house. big no no. the trust has yet to be settled and they are using the house that was given to me in the trust... anyhow. i've decided to WALK AWAY and cut the toxic people out of my life. i'll NEVER talk to my dad or sister. if they died tomorrow i'd go take a BIG healthy dump on the grave.
you don't need them in your life do you? do they contribute in a POSITIVE way to your life?
walk away. and in the future, they ask you what happened, say $2000, happened. they chose to end things with you over 2 grand. and a hard lesson needed for a punk kid.
you did right. just hold your ground.
 
Thanks for the personal examples. Seems I came to a decent decision. The house I am in, I bought from my parents (Full market value) with the understanding it will always be the family house. That has obviously changed.

When I sent money back I explained the ins company will be seeking deductibles so I didn't want to muddy up the water with accepting their cashiers checks. Especially when they never communicated anything to us about it.
 
My wife's brother is a toxic person. I never liked him, but never said anything because you never criticize the family of your spouse. Anyhow, it took twenty years and a number of episodes but she figured it out. It really hurt her, but she realizes that she is much better off without the repetitive drama.

As others have said, nephew has never learned responsibility and is enabled by parent and family. Eat your $2K, be thankful no physical injuries, close the door, and look forward to a better tomorrow.

My opinion: you did the right thing.
 
. Seems strange he is supporting his daughter and not the guy to lives close and takes care of thigns for him.

This ^^^^^^^^^ I have seen many times in my life and without fail the one that stays and helps with the parents is treated the worst.....sometimes by the parents and almost always by the siblings after the parents pass away. I do not get it. And if the parents leave anything in the will to that child that stayed and helped it gets even worse.

You have simply started weeding them out early......
 
Back
Top