I have the "EZ-Drain," which uses the tube. Screwing the tube on takes about two seconds and eliminates splashing oil. I store it in a plastic freezer bag in my tool box behind the cab. No muss, no fuss.
The two things that would worry me about the other "fingertip" valve type device would be that: A) It might be popped open when driving through tall, woody-stemmed brush, during off-road hunting, etc. Or, B) It'd would be easy for somebody to intentionally flip it open as as a prank, or an act of vandalism.
I've never seen one of these, so I could be very wrong about the chance of either type of inadvertent drain release happening. But the EZ-Drain is very secure, and fits flush with the bottom of the pan, similar to the original drain plug.
------------------
97 2500 4x4, club cab, auto, 3. 54 limited slip, JRE 4" exhaust, Dr. Performance Fuel system (370 HP), "Twister Turbo," Geno's guages -- Boost, EGT, transmission & Rear -- MAG Hytec covers, SunCoast Converter/Transgo shift kit, Brite Box, tons o'chrome under hood, Prime Loc, EZ Drain, Seat covers, wood dash, Rancho Suspension, Warn M12000 Winch on Warn Brush Guard, Warn driving and fog lights, Hella twin back up lights, 285/75/R16 B. F. G. ATs on Mickey Thompson "Classic" rims; Linex bed liner, BD exhaust brake, Optima, "Red-top" batteries. Northwest Custom mudflaps, front/rear, and stainless rocker panels.