Were you able to get the tap in farther than 1/4 inch? If so, then you must have missed the web in the middle but you didn't tap in far enough. Since it's a tapered thread, you've got to run the tap in far enough to give you enough engagement on the probe. When I do it I gradually run the tap in farther a few turns, then check how far the probe goes in. Once I get the probe to go in about 1/2 way, I stop tapping and tighten up the probe.
-Ryan