I agree, 100%.........
My company will check out every reference listed on an application before issuing a negative. We often run into exactly what you describe; one bad reference against several good. A lot of times, it will get cleared up in a pre-hire interview. Not all employers are good as gold either, in fact some are downright awfull towards their employees. Some of my best employees have recieved negative references from past employers. It seems that a good employee will get overloaded, making up for the bad ones, and usually get disgusted and quit. That employer gets ****** off because they just lost a good employee and they can't figure out why. DUH

So then you get the "they weren't worth a crap", "left me in a bind", "wouldn't hire them back", "weren't loyal", "couldn't get along with management", etc.....
It is a shame that it is the way it is. I can only see things getting worse, though. The American workforce, generally speaking, is overpaid, lazy, greedy, and self-serving. The American business community, generally speaking again, is not any better. There is very little loyalty and pride between employees and employers anymore, and that is devastating our economy. Employees want to get all that they can from their employers, and vice-versa, instead of working together to strenghthen their relaitionship. A prime example, since it's the kind of business I'm involved in, is the railroads. 20 years ago, when I first started contracting for the AT&SF, those railroaders were, for the most part, proud and loyal. They enjoyed their jobs, and would work all day long for the company. Today, you would be hard pressed to find a railroader who even likes his job and will put in a full days work for the company without *****in' about it. On the other hand, we don't have railroads anymore, we have BIG business on tracks, where every employee is nothing more than an expendable asset, to be used and abused, then tossed out and replaced by someone more "economically feasible".
I am not in any way an expert on business or economic issues. I just try to be a loyal and fair employer. I would probably be rich by now if I adopted the standards of todays business ethics.
:{ :{ :{ SAD, SAD, SAD :{ :{ :{