Well this is what i come up with, . . the Scotty II will pull cooler air. The afe mega cannon will pull more air and be fairly cool. They are both loud with a big turbo. I had the B-1 and PDR 40 sucking through both and they both scream, i thinking that the Scotty II is a little more loader though. If u don't like the extra noise and plan to block off the top air hole going the the cowl, then i would not use a Scotty II and i would use the AFE mega cannon. Since both filters are AFE, i talked to them at the SEMA show. They said that the mega cannon will flow more for two reasons. The first is the vellosity stack inside the mega cannon filter and the second is that the Scotty II is a little restrictive around the filter. So, with this in mind, . . i would use the mega cannon on high HP needs. I would not use it on every application though. If u are not heavy fueled and are running and don't plan on running high HP, then i would stick with the box type AFE or K&N. They work great up to about 250-300 HP or so.