Here I am

Engine/Transmission (1998.5 - 2002) Lugging manual transmission truck...

Attention: TDR Forum Junkies
To the point: Click this link and check out the Front Page News story(ies) where we are tracking the introduction of the 2025 Ram HD trucks.

Thanks, TDR Staff

Engine/Transmission (1994 - 1998) Replace my lift pump??

Engine/Transmission (1994 - 1998) EGT and New Engine

Status
Not open for further replies.
The ever re-occuring VP-44 subject in another thread reminded me of 2 incidents I have had with my truck, and I wonder if any other late 2nd generation, manual transmission truck owners have seen this.



I have been slowed down when RV towing in the hills by traffic and road conditions, and so involved watching vehicles around me, that I wasn't noticing that my RPM's had dropped too low to properly maintain speed or accellerate - even tho' I still had the pedal down trying to gain speed as conditions improved.



The truck eventually gave a "hiccup" - or momentarily cut out, bur immediately resumed proper operation, and of course, I realized my RPM was too far down, so downshifted, and all was normal - except for a "check engine" light on the instrument panel, and a P0216 code that went away after a few routine engine starts.



The last such incident was nearly 2 years ago - NO further incidents (OR lugging by the driver!) and no codes or poor engine operation at ANY time.



Anyone else ever done that, and got similar results with the CE light and resulting code?



My theory is that the ECM sees the RPM and accellerator position, and matches that with the failure for the engine to gain RPM, and assumes a problem with the injection pump and sets the code and CE warning - perhaps a normal result of lugging for any extended period of time?



Dunno if this would be a possible circumstance only with specific year trucks, depending on varying ECM programming for various years - so it might require another '02, manual transmission truck to get a meaningful comparison - I'm not concerned about this, or worried about my VP - just curious as to whether others might have had the same experience, and if my theory is accurate...



Any help?
 
OH, I might comment, I have seen that same "hiccup" when using the cruise control, and hitting a grade where engine speed could not be maintained - the engine hiccups, the CC drops out, and all is OK, no codes or CE light - but in that case, the lugging is short-term, and the ECM quickly makes it's own correction by kicking out the CC - something it CAN'T do when the brain dead driver is forcing the engine to do something it's incapable of... :rolleyes:
 
I have lugged my truck a few times with a heavy load on, and hae never gotten a check engine light, or codes. The engine did start to shutter once it dropped below 1200, but I think that was more of a clutch chatter then an engine issue.
 
I might add that in the scenarios described above, I have had the Comp on - dunno what that tosses into the mix - might be a contributing factor...



I'd drop Edge an Email and ask if that is something common to their Comp - but they rarely/never reply to their emails, so not much point... :(
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top