Matt, I know it doesnt make sense,and usually you are correct,but with the torque curve of the cummins(especially with a torque plate,or fueling box),and the way a chrysler auto works(line rise,and the way it shifts,only 1 overrunning clutch in the main trans,it all combines to make a light footed trans more likely to burn up in most cases.
a light footed chrysler auto will take more time to shift between 2nd and 3rd gear,since 3rd pushes off second in the chrysler auto,this means the 3rd clutches,and 2nd band will hang longer,and the overlap will burn 3rd faster than a heavy footed driver will,his shifts occur quickly and positive since his foots in it,hes got lots of line rise,RPM,and pressure. When used with a box or torque plate, the problem gets magnified because now you have the same power at 1/4 throttle that you used to at 3/4 throttle,yet you only have a small amount of line rise. So pressures are lower than stock for the same amount of power as stock. Now a light footed driver waits for the tc to lock then pushes lightly on the throttle,even towing on grades,with a box or plate, this is all ok if your trans is modded for it,but a stock trans isnt and this is when it slips,on hills, rolling into it in lockup. A heavy footed driver nails it it pops out of lockup,or even if it stays in,hes got full line pressure and more RPM since it probably dropped a gear. The Cummins motor at 1500-1700 can hurt the stock auto real easy,even mildly bombed motors. Light footed guys LOVE that RPM range,us heavy footed guys use throttle,rom and fluid coupling to get up to speed then lockup to cruise,a light footed guy goes easy as he can til it the tc locks,then they try to accelerate in lockup(this keeps the motor quieter,and revvinng less)this isnt conductive to long trans life. Most of my friends drive there trucks hard all have over 100K on them and no one has had to rebuild them. However i see guys who baby them burn them up much more often. Ill keep driving mine like I stole it,its way more fun
