This is exactly whu we NEED A REAL PLAYOFF!!!!
This is NOT a National Championship Game - no matter how much they try and tell you it is... ..... it's all smoke and mirrors - and nobody is more of a college football fan than myself - but using a phony computer ranking system is ridiculous!!!!!!!!!!!
Here's a fantastic article on this... ... ... ...
http://www.oregonlive.com/sports/or...sports/1167798332304180.xml&coll=7&thispage=1
Boise State win exposes failure of BCS formula
Wednesday, January 03, 2007
SCOTTSDALE, Ariz. I t's time, past time really, for all involved to admit the Bowl Championship Series is a colossal failure.
Once again the BCS and its insistence that a convoluted, virtually incomprehensible mathematical formula pick the two teams that play for the title, has blown the opportunity to give the highest echelon of college football a true national champion.
Let's pretend for a moment the BCS is something more than a tool for the six power conferences -- the Atlantic Coast, Big East, Big Ten, Big 12, Pacific-10 and Southeastern -- to monopolize the money and corporate sponsorship opportunities that go hand-in-hand with the major bowl games.
Let's pretend the BCS really wants to give college football's best team the chance to win the title on the field.
So, why isn't Boise State part of the conversation?
The Broncos (13-0) are one of two unbeaten Division I-A teams.
They knocked off every bowl team on their schedule.
They crushed Sun Bowl-champion Oregon State by four touchdowns a few weeks before OSU knocked off Rose Bowl-champion USC.
In Monday's Fiesta Bowl, Boise State stunned big, bad Oklahoma, one of the elite programs in college football, and did it with the kind of drama, flair and panache all too often missing in the major bowls.
A misdirection, hook-and-lateral for one touchdown? A sleight-of-hand Statue of Liberty for the winning two-point conversion? The star tailback concluding a postgame national television interview on one knee, proposing to his girlfriend?
was the most entertaining finish to a college football game since Doug Flutie cranked up to throw the Hail Mary. Heck, it was better than that. It probably was the best finish ever.
It would have been nice to see Boise State get a shot at No. 1 Ohio State, but the Broncos never had a chance.
The jury-rigged, gerrymandered BCS formula is front-loaded to exclude schools from mid-major conferences from the Big Game.
The mid-majors rarely begin the season high in the polls, and never get a chance to climb because the big programs refuse to engage.
Oh, sure, Auburn or Louisiana State or Michigan might condescend to let a Boise State, Fresno State or Texas Christian play them as visitors. That way the power-conference programs maximize the gate receipts from their giant stadiums and lean on the homefield advantage to shorten the odds.
But Auburn, LSU or Michigan wouldn't be caught dead on Boise State's smurf turf. Do that, and the average fan might begin believing teams in the Mountain West and Western Athletic Conferences can play with the big boys.
Elbowed out of meaningful early-season games, the mid-majors rarely get a real chance to go very far in the computer rankings. It's like running the 400 meters against record-setting U. S. runner Jeremy Wariner, and giving him a 50-meter start.
The power conferences allow a mid-major school into one of the consolation BCS games, providing it meets certain criteria. Boise State jumped through all the hoops to reach the Fiesta Bowl, which was played on the same field where Florida and Ohio State will play for the title Monday.
The Broncos were supposed to be happy just to be there, take their thumping and go home quietly.
Surprise. When the cleanup crews finished sweeping up the confetti at University of Phoenix Stadium, Boise State still was standing unbeaten, a party-crasher at the BCS coronation. And one that suddenly is hard to ignore.
The contrast with Michigan couldn't have been more telling. Unlike Boise State, Michigan had real national championship hopes from fall camp. Had the Wolverines been four points better at Ohio State on Nov. 18, they would have been playing next week for the national championship.
Yep, that is the same Michigan team exposed by USC on Monday in the Rose Bowl as having a deficient secondary, a plodding offensive line and unimaginative offense.
It's easy to see now that Michigan had absolutely no business in the BCS championship game, but the Wolverines nearly slid in anyway.
Boise State proved two things Monday:
College football would be a better and more entertaining product if every deserving team had an honest chance to win the title.
And the current system is a colossal failure.