I know you said between the valve covers, but I have another thought. When I changed the head studs on my '97, the studs were a hair too long. I had to grind a small amount out of the inside of a couple of the covers for the cover to seat properly. The studs were hitting the inside of the covers and letting a small amount of oil to leak out between the cover, gasket and head. This may not be your case, but just an idea.