I think they're necessary for the guys who want to get cab heat faster. I've never had one, and I don't need one. I drove to SD last Christmas in below zero temps with plenty of heat in my cab, and the engine temp sat right at 190 - as it always does. So, I chucked my piece of cardboard that I brought along just in case. I figured If I didn't use it on that trip, I'd never need it. Mine heats up fast enough, so I don't see a need - for me. A lot of guys like them, though, and I think the older trucks may need them more than the newer ones.