I'm trading off a Ford F550 that has run at 19,500 lbs for the past 450K miles... we use card locks and can track almost all fuel through this truck in the past 8 years... .
We are putting into service a 5500 rated at 19,500 and it now has 9,000 miles and is seeing its next oil change... ... so far we've not seen the change oil light...
Currently with just 9,000 miles were seeing better fuel economy on the 08 than the Ford... using it on the same runs, and hauls by almost 2 1/2 mpg... . as long as it stays better than..... and the repair costs are less than those of the F550 we'll be very happy... ...
We've found that you really can't judge fuel economy over 10 tanks of fuel... . but by looking back 25,000 or 50,000 miles you get a much better overall picture... .
BTW - Ford, just under 10, Dodge just over 11. 5 to date... .