My advice, from personal experience with the Mallory,would be to put a filter pre-pusher pump. I had a sediment bowl type 'filter' when my first Mallory died, Mallory stated that failed due to sediment causing caviatation in the gerator. I believe all the Carter pumps are 'vaned'. I don't know, wish I did, if that type of system is more or less prone to failure from debris, but a filter of some sort, I'm currently using a Earl's screen type filter, certainly won't hurt you. Just be sure to pick one that is not restrictive. The Earl's is rated at 5 GPM, more than enough, but maybe not the best choice if you are going to use the rubber line, too many fittings to make it work. If you are going to upgrade to braided SS line, the Earl's filter just simply screws in line, piece O cake.
Others are running without pre-filters and having good results, but IMHO, you are taking a chance that is easily prevented when doing the install.
Can anyone tell me which is more prone to debris failure, vaned or gerator type pumps? I know the tolerances are fairly tight with the gerator pumps, I have never seen the inside of a vaned pump, just curious.
Scott W.