Hello all, I just purchased a 99 3500 quad cab a month ago based on what I have read on TDR. I am an ex ford dealer technician that had to work on the p. o. s power strokes the first 2 or 3 years they came out, which were the nightmare years for them. I love the simplicity of the Cummins and the overall design will definitely outlast the Ford/Navistar combination. I will always
race Fords when it comes to gas motors but the Dodge/Cummins combination makes a much more reliable and stronger combination for towing than a power stroke.
Well anyway, here's my 2 cents opinion on the full coolant bottle and low radiator. If you don't find any external leak in the cooling system or a bad cap then the only thing that comes to my mind is a cenario that I have seen alot on a few forced induction/nitrous gas motors. Sometimes under extreme cylinder pressures the head actually lifts enough to breach the head gasket/fire ring seal and actually pumps some cylinder pressure into the cooling system therefore pushing more coolant into the recovery bottle than just the thermal expansion of the cooling system by itself. Then when the cooling system cools down, only a certain amount of vacuum is created which is only enough to recover the amount of coolant discharged into the recovery bottle from thermal expansion, and not enough to suck in the extra amount of coolant that was pushed out by cylinder pressure leakage. In all the cenarios that I have seen/diagnosed there was no water found in the crakcase oil at all, just only the recovery bottle that never goes down and a radiator that can't stay full. In a lot of these cases, when the engine was not worked hard for a period of time, then there would not be near as much extra coolant in the recovery bottle if at all. Small block Chevys have less of a problem like this because they have 5 more head bolts than a small block Ford which helps with head gasket retention under extreme cylinder pressures. I don't claim as of yet to be an expert on Cummins engines, but I just thought I would share some of my head scratching experiences with you since what you describe yours is doing sounds familiar.