Here I am

Ranch Hand vs. Concrete Pier (long)

Attention: TDR Forum Junkies
To the point: Click this link and check out the Front Page News story(ies) where we are tracking the introduction of the 2025 Ram HD trucks.

Thanks, TDR Staff

Truck gauges 04.5

Tire Balancing Powder

Status
Not open for further replies.
Last week I pulled the stupidest move of my life (well, second stupidest, counting my ex :rolleyes: ). Exiting the parking garage from work, another vehicle kinda caught my attention heading left up the ramp. ‘Funny how one tends to turn left when looking left… and I turned directly into a 3’X3’ steel reinforced concrete pier. It was my first wreck in 38 years of driving - a solid little “love tap” at almost a perfect 45 degree angle – and I didn’t even realize it was there until after impact. Two things came to mind instantly: #1) I done f***ed up, and #2) no amount of hind-sighting, second-guessing, re-living, wishing or praying could change what had just happened to my pride and joy. So I backed ‘er up and pulled into an empty stall (which is easy when they’re all empty – I work some long hours) to assess damage.



My 12-day old Ranch Hand front bumper replacement had taken quite a shot. It was pretty much completely intact, but a little bent towards the right side, and of course a tad scarred where it and the concrete had attempted to become one. I knew it wasn’t good, but I was immediately wondering – can I drive it? I saw nothing of a liquid nature dripping to the ground, so I figured I’d try to get it home.



Driving the 16 miles was uneventful and thankfully, that tough Beast drove straight and true, but I’m sure I saw more of my gauges than I did the road. OK – got home and still no leaks. ‘Drove it back to work the next morning with no problem (not counting that my lighting was somewhat diminished except for that little patch about three feet in front of the left side of the truck) I called my insurance company and told them what happened. They asked me several questions and whether or not I’d called for a police report and I was thinking to myself, What? With no witnesses, no injuries and no damage to anything except my truck, I’d call the police so they could write a report that said, “This moron drove himself right into a brick wall. ”??? Well anyway, insurance covers it (minus my $1,000 deductible, of course. Ouch!).



So I went on down to their recommended collision center (after they couldn’t figure out how to pay the claim since I actually indicated I wanted to do as much of the repair as possible myself - no one had ever asked them that before). That was the first time I saw what that five MPH concrete “meeting” did: The Ranch Hand was pushed back and to the right, taking the left front quarter with it. It had pushed back far enough that the grille was busted, and the hood was in the Ranch Hand’s unyielding grip. The hood had bowed up, but not until it had seriously gouged the passenger door. Underneath is when it came to me that the Ranch Hand might have saved me from The Beast being totaled: the ½” thick steel mounting brackets were bent into little “S” shapes in each side, and the frame had actually ripped where the Ranch Hand mounted!:eek: Holy Moly! What would have happened had all that heavy (245 lbs. ) steel not been there?



Well, everything will be fixed and/or replaced – including my Ranch Hand! But the damages came to just shy of $6,300.



So what do you think? Did the Ranch Hand save my bacon on this? I wonder how much further into the engine area that pier would have gone without it…
 
Last edited:
I hit a deer at 55 mph last may, $6,700 dollars later I had replaced the POS plastic with a ranchand bumper as well as most of the rest of the front of the truck. Then in June I nail a deer going about 40 or so, and then again in August going about 50. Those second two deer gave me about a thousand gray hairs but not even a fleck of paint off the bumper. Took it home sprayed it off and you would never know.



So YES absolutely I think that bumper saved ya. Also as an EMT for many years I can tell ya accidents such as yours have been very costly to peoples lives and abilities as well. It doesn't have to be a high speed impact to kill or hurt you real bad. Every bit of protection is worth it in my opinion.



I would make sure they double or even triple check that frame to make sure it is not bent though and if it is that it is fixed properly. Then throw another Ranchhand on there and drive with some assurance you have something that WILL stand between you and whatever is coming.



Jon
 
So are all the states east of the Rockies littered with deer. I keep seeing these reports from you folks. This is making me wonder about a trip to MI this summer. My family members in MI keep hitting deer at night.



All that damage from 5mph, what would have happened with a stock bumper. Totaled I guess.
 
Originally posted by BillGotthelf

Cowboy Medic what the heck are you doing with all those deer? Do you have little deer painted on you door for each "kill"?:D



Don't need a hunting licence then, do ya. :)
 
Ouch!!! Sorry to hear about your mishap. Ranch hand makes very strong bumpers and will protect you in most cases. The only thing with strong bumpers, is the frame is now the weak link. So that means the frame may giveway first. On the Ute and TJM has designed the mounting "system" to give way, which takes the stress off of the frame. I don't know if Ranch hand takes that into effect or not.



One question, Is the pole still standing?
 
At the risk of offending all the Ranchhand owners, I'd say it hurt you more than helped you. While that bumper will definitely save you with deer and most vehicles, hitting an immovable object with a super-strong bumper mounted to your frame is not good. Something has to give, such as your frame, as mentioned above by lgibson.



I T-boned an F250 at 40mph with my stock bumper on my last 2500. I totalled the Ford. Damage to my truck was extensive to the body and radiator, but I had no frame or engine damage. In fact the engine was still running after I hit him. If you'd seen my truck you would have thought it was totalled. Damage went all the way back to the passenger door, which I couldn't open. But the body shop made it good as new. You could never tell by looking at it that it was massively crumpled.



That "wimpy" bumper may be an expensive PITA when you hit a deer or smaller vehicle, but it may help save your life when you run into a concrete bridge abutment.
 
Tulsa618... ... ... So was it the vehicle that cought your eye... ... . or the pretty little woman driving it? If it was a woman driving it I sure hope she was worth the look!!!!!



Jason
 
Tulsa618, I feel your pain. I had only had my truck back about 2 mos after a deer had wiped out the side of the truck when I side-swiped a light pole in a parking lot. I was looking for a way out of the lot and did not see the pole ( dark brown pole not lit at night). Needless to say the passenger side quad door was totaled with a little damage before and after the door. The truck never slowed down (about 5-10 mph) and it bumped very little. The aluminum light pole was crimped nearly in half and the concrete footing was pushed over about 6-8 inches. Total damage to truck was 3100 dollars. I'm paying for most of the damage due to insurance premium surcharge of 1500 dollars over 3 yrs and the 500 dollar deductable :( Got to love those stupid mistakes. :rolleyes:
 
don't feel too bad, one night i was making a u turn in a empty parking lot and didn't see a light pole in front of me, i caught that front drivers side wheel on the corner of the concrete base, didn't do any body damage but destroyed a wheel, spindle upper control arm, gear box (i think the box was good but dealer said it jumped teeth inside???) bent the frame at the upper control arm, compressed a front spring and bent the u bolds holding the rear end on the drivers side... after it came out the bill was around 6500. 00 i believe. :--)
 
Dang! 'Just goes to show it doesn't take much to cause a boatload of damage!



Royk, I agree totally that "something has to give. " And I take no offense whatever. In this case, I at least had a driveable truck after impact. Without the Ranch Hand, I'd have been calling for a tow for sure! At least the part of the frame that "gave" was just the very front-most portion that held the bumper. I feel really lucky that the rest of the frame seems to be untouched.
 
Just a lil list of stuff I have "bumped"

1. Ford Explorer= The lady said dont worry about it

2. Toyota truck= Shot it across the 4 lane intersection. The guy was drunk and went on his way with a WRECKED truck

3. Toyota truck= Insurance paid for it.

4. Honda Civic hatchback= the guy said he was sorry lol

5. My friends 1966 Impala that he thinks is worth a million dollars. the worst part was he was standing right next to it! Small dent

6. Brand new BMW the guy called my insurance agent and said I hit and ran him... ... makes you wonder how he got my insurance infromation FROM ME! lol

7. A few Deer and a million bunnies!
 
Just a lil list of stuff I have "bumped"

1. Ford Explorer= The lady said dont worry about it

2. Toyota truck= Shot it across the 4 lane intersection. The guy was drunk and went on his way with a WRECKED truck

3. Toyota truck= Insurance paid for it.

4. Honda Civic hatchback= the guy said he was sorry lol

5. My friends 1966 Impala that he thinks is worth a million dollars. the worst part was he was standing right next to it! Small dent

6. Brand new BMW the guy called my insurance agent and said I hit and ran him... ... makes you wonder how he got my insurance infromation FROM ME! lol

7. A few Deer and a million bunnies!



Hey, uh, could you fill in your location so the rest of us know where to watch for you... ?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top