Is this hand calculated over at least an tank of fuel?
The overhead is usually only a reference, but when you throw a box at it, it goes totally berzerk!
These MPG posts and the overhead readings kinda remind me of a 70 something Monte Carlo a buddy of mine had. It had a huge gage, the same size and right beside the speedo. Same sweep too, like 270 degrees. It had (going by memeory) a color scale an some text something like "economy" and "bad economy" LOL. It was only too obvious that it was nothing more than a vacuum gage :-laf
Our overheads usually aren't much better! Mine reads 21 something and haven't reset is in months. Hand calculation shows maybe 16 on a good day.