Same here, it doesn't stay on the shelf to go bad! Biggest thing that was a problem with the Walmart DEF was seals loose under the caps! Haven't seen the box type yet around me, was still in the blue jugs. Looks like they are all coming out of same plant, just different boxes going around the jugs! I've used Walmart and Travelers from TSC. No problems with them. Can't seem to pay the price for any other jug/box brands as DEF has to be made to a certain spec! Waiting for the code breakers to give us more info to use.