Dresselered, I don't know if the carbon provides a conductive path or becomes an insulator. As an electrical engineer, I find it hard to believe that the soot or haze can affect these things, but they are sensitive. Very sensitive. I have never seen specs on what coatings do to them and have never worked in an environment where the thermistors getting dirty was a problem. All of this is speculation on my part where I'm seeing something and trying to figure out what the cause is. I get over 21 mpg most of the time and I believe (again I'm speculating) that it is a combination of small things I've done rather than one big fix. Changing my IAT was one of them. Cleaning mine didn't do very much but it did a little. One more observation so you get the whole picture. When I first went to clean mine, I put the socket on the sensor, got the extension in and snapped in the ratchet. It took almost zero pressure to turn the sensor. When I put it back in, I snugged it up good to seat the O ring. That probably helped, too.
Pit Bull, I check mine at 20K. I think it can tell you alot by looking at it. For instance, if you run a oiled air filter, that will definitely affect the performance of the IAT if oil is getting on it. All the ones I've looked at without the E Brake have a brown haze like spark plugs get. Be careful not to break the thermistor off during cleaning. E Brake ones I've seen actually have a coating of black soot. I used brake cleaner and Q tips and it cleaned right up.
Dresselered, that makes me think. I wonder if the haze builds a "track" between the leads down inside the protective case and possibly changes the resistance. The haze track may be conductive enough to change the resistance. Don't know. And you can't get down in there to see.