For a 37 I'd run 4. 56 or 4. 88. Do a google search for gear ratio calculator and you'll be able to run the numbers to see what your cruising RPMs are.
I put 4. 10s in my truck from 3. 55s. With 35s I do just over 70mph at 2000rpm. Pretty much what 3. 55s and stock tires would put me.
Randy's Ring and Pinion is who I got my stuff from, both in the Jeep and the truck. I'm pleased with the Yukon brand gears. Setup nice and good quality.
Keep in mind cheap gears aren't going to give you good results... such as Genuine Gear, or Gen-u-whine as most people call them because they are LOUD!