Rusty,
I see your point, but let me ask you this. Who is the service manager going to give more attention to. A kind, elder gentleman, who has been a repeat customer, or a kind 20-somthing kid, who he has never seen before, and might not ever see again?
I have experanced this at SEVERAL dealers around town. I am always "yes sir" with them, and "no sir", and have told them stright to the point what I think is the problem, yet they have the attutide of "how does this kid think he knows more then me,
I am the one who knows". It's always a "Holyer then thou" attude I get at most ANY Napa, AutoZone, O'Rilies, or a HOST of OTHER business.
I think if you KNOW your service manager/writer it makes a HUGE difference, but peoples perception of you will change how they treat you, which is sad. I had a GREAT guy at the old Chevy dealership I used to goto, but he left. Then I was up a creak.
My point is that it's not ALWAYS the customers fault for being treated how you get treated. I have never done the "dearler rating" thing, but I was almost scred at the dealer once. That was enough for me not to take it back again to ANY dealer. One bad apple I know.
Getting off soapbox, and zipping up the flame-proof vest,
Andrew