Here I am

Repair Nightmare - Oil Leak

Attention: TDR Forum Junkies
To the point: Click this link and check out the Front Page News story(ies) where we are tracking the introduction of the 2025 Ram HD trucks.

Thanks, TDR Staff

Edge EGT Probe

2 gauges off of 1 thermocouple?

Status
Not open for further replies.
I've had a bit of a truck repair nightmare that just won't stop!! Over Thanksgiving '08 I "burned up" my 04. 5 engine - apparently a broken ring on #1 lead to no oil which lead to a bad problem!! Found out the hard way that the oil pressure gauge is just an idiot light of sorts and not really helpful for heading off a problem but that's another issue. Long story short, my motor seized up about the exact moment the check gauges light/alarm came on!



I trailered my truck home and dropped it off at a local performance diesel shop that seemed to be doing good business at the time... good reviews in the mags and lotsa rigs around town flying their colors. They got my motor broke down relatively quick with a list of repairs we needed to do. First off, get engine to machine shop - that took over two months just to get it to a machine shop!! In the interim, their phone went off the hook, the shop got pretty dark and on the occasions I could find somebody, they assured me all was well - just waiting on machining. Times are tough right now, I understand and sympathize with that, so I point blank asked if they were in business, would my truck get repaired appropriately or just thrown back together and get me out the door. I was assured the engine would be fresh and done right. Finally over 3 months after I dropped it off it was repaired... supposedly.



The little things I've noticed so far - AC doesn't work, windshield wiper fluid sprays onto the ground, a wire with quick connect just hanging down below the fuse box that I for the life of me can't figure out where it goes.



The big thing, and my question after venting a little - it's got a big oil leak that I just can't see where it's coming from. It's out the front and hits the fan so oil is blown all over the front of the engine, mostly driver side, front axle assembly is completely covered. Initially looked like just some dripping oil that I thought might clear up but decided last week after watching it for a week it's got a for real problem. Contacted the shop and was told "mechanic would be back next week", they'll get it all fixed up right. They'll call me... hah, now can't get ahold of the shop/anybody.



Sooo, time to cut my losses and get it to a better business. I know it's pretty vague on the leak, I just can't see down in behind the belts/hoses etc. to see what's going on. Wondering if anyone might have an idea on what might commonly cause this after a rebuild so I can kind of decide where/what to do next. If I was keen on taking my truck to a dealer I would have taken it there in the first place... not keen on the dealer!! :-laf Thanks for any help or ideas - not looking at harassing the shop that did the "repair", just one of life's lessons I'll have to live with.
 
Holy crap. Did you pay that shop with a cc? I dunno if you can, but I'd check into disputing the charge if so.



Your best bet may be taking it to the dealer now. Your description is vague but could be a lot of things in that area. I'd start by checking around the valve cover/rocker arm/head and working down from there. I'd also be concerned the head gasket is jacked. You could always check the oil for coolant, etc...



How did you break a ring? Freak accident? Do you have any mods?
 
Not sure how I broke a ring - it was bone stock, 135K miles. Shop mechanic said he'd seen a handful of 04. 5's with same problem. Scored 5 & 6 cylinders pretty bad - of course 1 was toast. 5 piston looked pretty bad - had bad injector. Can't believe the thing was running as good as it was... then screeeech!



Doesn't appear to be coming from valve cover and I checked coolant - looked pretty pristine.



Honestly, I paid with a check and got the heck outta there - I honestly thought they'd have buttoned it up fine. Had them add gauges and an Air Dog as well - those things are working fine! If the thing will work, I've gott a PSM intake and Smarty Jr. standing by. Too bad, I think the shop was capable of quality work - I'm thinking their business didn't fail, they failed their business!



Got a line on reputable mechanics/shop today and we'll get it in on Monday. Hopefully not gonna be another multi $$$$$ deal!
 
Got my truck looked at and sounds like it was a mess:



(1) big oil leak from a completely uninstalled plug/cover to injection pump access hole

(2) a cross member cut to remove the engine was not rewelded on re-install and bolts not reinstalled

(3) missing exhaust bolts, missing WS washer pump bolts

(4) wrongly routed cables to intake heater - rubbed completely thru by front pulley with raw wires exposed (raw wires/sparks/flying leaking oil - bad combo!)



Sounds like it's not even my original engine - appears to be a "re-core" or something like that vs. my machined original. Makes sense as the original shop told me I needed all new injectors as the old ones were completely shot (truck wouldn't have even run if that were the case!!) Current repair shop believes they just ordered a re-man unit and built from there. Bunch of crap. Good part is, should be able to get it fixed up and generally have new engine with lotsa life in it (fingers crossed!)



Ive tried multiple times to contact the original shop without success. Honestly the wasted money doesn't bother me nearly as much as the lack of honesty and integrity. I can tolerate alot of crap and understand bad things happen but to be dishonest or deceptive just doesn't set well with me. So long story short, I hate to publicly discount any business but hate to see anybody else get taken - I would strongly, strongly advise avoiding Dominator Performance Diesel in Pocatello, ID. Doubt they are even in business any longer but I see their website is still up.
 
I'd run by the dealer and get the block serial based on the VIN and then tear them a new *******. Even if it is a reputable core engine, it wasn't agreed to.



Did your new shop take pics of what they found??
 
I hate to see a member get screwed, so some quick googling comes up with this (should you want to hold them accountable):



DominatorDiesel.com (Dominator Diesel) | MySpace.com

Bryan Jolley (Bryan Jolley) | MySpace.com



Could this be one of your mechanics?



#ad




Is this the money they took for your crappy repair job?



#ad




And the owners are/were/may be Sean and Bryan Jolley according to:



MerchantCircle.com | Customer Showcase



And they're also active on comp diesel's website,



New Black Turbo Socks Available - Competition Diesel. Com - Bringing The BEST Together



The Levi named in that thread is probably the same levi pictured in the myspace pages... I'm sure he could lead you in the right direction.



Oh and where there's smoke, there's fire. The Levi guy says they've been working in Wyoming. Sounds like you're not the only person to get screwed: DPDIESEL anyone know how to get ahold of him - Competition Diesel. Com - Bringing The BEST Together



There are more threads like that on comp diesel's website.



Good luck man. Hope everything works out and you get refunded.
 
Holy cow!!!!! I can't believe how apparently calm you are with all of this! If your story is accurate, you were clearly the victim of criminal activity. If it were me I'd be looking to sue them back to the stone age (which may be the reason they're going out of business in the first place).

I suppose you could take some comfort that in the end, what comes around goes around.

Ryan
 
Oh yah, we've got plenty of pictures of the empty access cover dripping oil out of it, empty bolt holes, a nice clean cut thru the crossmember but not fixed, a fried wire loom with exposed bare wire (that's a little scary looking with bare wires and melted wires covers surrounded by oil dripping off everything!)



I'm a pretty easy going guy - maybe that's to my own downfall. I dropped my truck off with 'em, came and checked out the damage when they had the engine on the ground, trusted those guys to do it right, tried not to harass 'em about getting it done as they actually looked to me like they had more than enough work in the shop at the time. I'm an adult, I could have taken it elsewhere, if they screwed me they screwed me - they gotta live with their behavior not me. Kill 'em with kindness man!! Being a single guy with a good income and plenty of $$ helps temper rage too!! ;) Like I said, I'm alot more disappointed in the low integrity and poor pride of workmanship they exhibited than PO'd for them making off with a few of my bucks. Levi seemed a decent and helpful fellar - if I was him I'd get some different business associates if I wanted to have a successful, credible business.



Nuff said, hopefully back on the road next week for another 135K miles!!
 
Last edited:
What i cannot comprehend is the things that you described probably could not be done by an illegal Guatemalan picked up from the corner of Main street who is given the task of putting the engine back in the truck. I have pulled a few engines in my time, mostly fox body Mustangs and i'm trying to picture the shop, the mechanics, and who in their right mind forgets to do those things and lets a vehicle leave their shop that way even if they are closing their doors. The only conclusion i can come up with is that the person(s) working on your truck were highly intoxicated, high, or dillusional at the time the work was completed. I am sorry if i have ofended you in any way and i don't mean to but it just doesn't compute.
 
What i cannot comprehend is the things that you described probably could not be done by an illegal Guatemalan picked up from the corner of Main street who is given the task of putting the engine back in the truck. I have pulled a few engines in my time, mostly fox body Mustangs and i'm trying to picture the shop, the mechanics, and who in their right mind forgets to do those things and lets a vehicle leave their shop that way even if they are closing their doors. The only conclusion i can come up with is that the person(s) working on your truck were highly intoxicated, high, or dillusional at the time the work was completed. I am sorry if i have ofended you in any way and i don't mean to but it just doesn't compute.



X2! :mad::rolleyes:



:-laf:-laf
 
Haha, no offense here! Only thing I can figure is the thing actually ran pretty nice, quiet, and smooth. I've got no complaints with how the truck ran as it seemed fine performance wise so maybe they just assumed job well done. I dunno! Maybe a simple return phone call with an explanation would've answered that question aye!!?? If I hadn't noticed the oil dripping on the concrete at my home, never had to use my windshield wiper fluid, didn't have to use the AC, and never went up in flames I'd have never known there was a problem either!! :-laf :-laf



Compute this:

#ad






#ad




#ad




#ad
 
Last edited:
If you lived by me i would fix it if you paid for parts, these trucks are pretty easy to take apart and assemble plus i have had mine apart alot, can usually look at a bolt and know where it goes
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top