The 5. 9 alt bracket you have was known to develope cracks and was replaced by one that looks like the 6. 7 you have. Mine was cracked by the time it had 5K on it. If they both hold the alt correctly (or with just a little grinding) then I would use the 6. 7 because I would bet the old sheetmetal bracket is cracked ~in fact, I think I can see the crack location in your pick - it's rusted where they crack. .
Good luck,
Scotty