I like the S & W's that I have they are some of the prettiest revolvers in my safe. The purchase of the Ruger was based on a couple of thoughts. Barrel length & ease of carry, whether it be in the saddle holster when horseback OR on the hip in a Western style holster. The Ruger's barrel length was a perfect match to both types of carry. I tried the Smith in the horse holster it was fine. In the Western style holster it for some reason just had a funky feel to the draw? Don't know why but it just didn't feel as Smooth as the Ruger. I use this gun as a "Work Gun" its line of work is defense in the field. I'm not saying that the Smith wouldn't have done this any differently, The Ruger just felt good in both holsters and in the hand, balance for such a Giant gun had been thought out very well and I don't think that reliability can be argued in either choice.