Again Harvey, I agree with you 90%. If he had bought the trailer first then bought his current truck to tow it, it would have been a mistake. But at the time he got the truck, there was no camper. He plans have definitely changed since his purchase. In early 06 I bought the biggest truck there was available at the time for my family of 6, two of which were in car seats. A quad cab simply did not work with the small back seat and at the time I placed the order, there was no talk yet of the dually. Also, here in western NYS, we get ALOT of snow. In the winter, I tow a 4 place enclosed trailer and even with aggressive AT tires, I can easily break my tires loose, intentionally or not. DRW would be worse with the added floatation the other 2 wheels provide.
Any transporter who drove a SRW 2500 short wheel base short bed would be an idiot in my opinion. It's not the right tool for the job. You have stated in the past that you have bought many tools from Wal-Mart knowing they were of good value and would do the work you had planned for them. No one here judges you for purchases (ok, some did but not me) and said that if you didn't have Matco, Snap-On etc tools that you had made a mistake in your tool selection. However, if you showed up at a Cummins repair shop as a mechanic with a plastic tool box filled with Wal-Mart tools, you would be escorted out the door before your name badge was printed.
Please don't think I am making a direct comparison of Wal-Mart tools to trucks. This long explanation is not to justify my purchases or his or yours, but to go through the decision making process of how I found that in 2006, a 3500 Mega Cab SRW was the best truck for me. You are fortunate that you have a dedicated truck to pull your camper and have a car and an awesome motorcycle to ride at 40 mpg when diesel prices are 4+ a gallon. Not everyone is that fortunate and their trucks must perform many different jobs. Some days my truck plays grocery getter and soccer dad duty, some days it is hauling stone and backhoes, some days hauling the camper and some days it's my date night vehicle. My truck does all of the jobs I have for it quite well but is not optimal for any single one job. I wish I could have a 5500 long haul for the camper, a 3500 pick up for the backhoe and stone, a 1500 for the snowmobile trailer and a Dakota for the grocery getting but I'm sure my accountant is going to disagree with me.
One of these days Harvey I want to come down to Texas, sit in your barn, have some beverages, shoot the bull. As my wife states frequently, I have a knack of being able to agree with people in the most disagreeable way. I call it having fun conversations.