I replaced mine about a month ago, and it has worked fine. I didnt overtighten it, because those gaskets look so thin and flimsy, I wanted a little room for them to give. The original lasted 2 years and was flat as paper when removed.
I was in a hurry to get it fixed, so I went with an OEM gasket. The next time I might get clear silicone, put a fine bead around the entire light fixture, and let it dry overnight before putting it back on. Would this work?? Would this keep it from sticking like glue when it needed to be removed again??