I just flushed out my Amsoil (saved it) and am giving the valvoline a try. so far I like it.
I have a transgo kit installed with firm shifts. With the amsoil, the shifts were snap fingers quick, but smooth. with the valvoline, they are quick and firm with a little kick, depending upon throttle position.
The Amsoil may be the better fluid. I'm a little concerned about it's wear charecteristics though. DTT seems to have documented some extra wear, which does not suprise me as this is a very slippery fluid, which probably produces more friction (two surfaces slipping past each other).
Will see which is best after a couple of weeks.
So far the amsoil is the better behaved in a heavy truck. In My 74 cuda, the valvoline would have been better. lighter car, firm shifts enjoyed, but in a 3 ton truck, that firmess might be a little harder on parts. (u-joints etc... )
absolutely no locking convertor clutch shudder. very well behaved.