Mine makes some noise at times. When it does make the noise, I can push the clutch in, move the shift lever around through the gears, then let the clutch out in neutral, and the sound goes away. The dealer said this is "normal" for these transmissions, and they claim it is from the gears rotating inside when in neutral.
As far as shifting goes, I couldn't't ask for a smoother shifting manual transmission. Everyone that drives my truck comments on how nicely it shifts... ... ... ... ... even my wife! It does have the XXXXXX 5W-30 synthetic engine oil in it however.
Wayne
amsoilman