There is nothing wrong with a O-ring seal, my MagHytec cover has been on for 4 years+ and has never leaked a drop. The O-ring in my opinion is the best method to seal the differential covers. They allow cover removal with out the fuss and mess of the gasket sealer, and the re-installation of a simple bolt on. There are many other makes of rear covers, so it you would like to be different, just look thought some 4x4 magazines, or scout the web. Most others though will seal with a gasket and or sealant, nothing wrong with it, just be aware.