You have some other draw... . a glove box light is not a large enough draw to drain the two batteries in two days... these are 100 amp hour batteries... assuming your replacements are up to standards...
An example of that is a 100 amp draw would drain 1 battery in 1 hour... . a 1 amp draw would require 100 hours to drain 1 battery... this is a simple math formula you can figure out... and of course you have 2 batteries... .
If you have something wrong with your charging system, or bad batteries, the above goes out the window as the batteries are not fully charged...
Some times short trippers, those who take very short trips in very cold weather don't allow the vehicle to run long enough to recharge the batteries and they will go down... .
A couple of simple tests... . if you can spin the alternator pulley the belt is too loose... . what your voltmeter gauge for the gauge to move from discharge at start up to charge 5-7 minutes later. .
Put an AC volt meter across the batteries... if AC voltage over 3-4 volts is present, one or more of the diodes in the diode bridge is bad in the alternator and the vehicle will not charge...
And with every thing turned off... remove the ground strap to one battery and place a DC amp meter between the ground strap and the post of the second battery, to see how much drain you have... .
Remember you might have to watch it for 15-20 minutes to see if something is turning on or off... ... cycling so to speak... based on what you said, and the ability of good batteries to function, you'd need a drain of more than 3-5 amps to bring the condition of the batteries to a point where it won't crank or start. .
Also remember that a bad connection, on the cables, solenoid or starter, and or a bad starter can cause the same problems... .
Hope this helps...