I had the 3rd Gen filters from Geno's on my '05 and was NOT impressed. The plastic tangs that clipped into the fresh air grille started to break after a month. After a few months, the tangs were almost all broken, so I took the filters off (came in two parts) and threw the whole thing away. I think the 2nd Gen filters attach differently than the 3rd Gen filters. If anybody has anything good to say about the 2nd Gen filters, I'd love to hear about it.