After discounting the outfitter, I took one last look at the snug top. The lines are a little more refined cosmetically. I liked the idea of easy removal, but decided it would probably end up on all the time anyway. They had a slick little fold-down window against the cab window. It seemed to be the best of the fiberglass products. I’d also followed the stories about windows popping out, and glass doors shattering.
Biggest reasons I got the Caravan:
- more durable (beyond any doubt in my mind)
- more secure. The glass door of a shell is begging to be broke into
- I really wanted the double doors for easier access to the truck with my trailer on when traveling. I didn’t want to lift a door, and drop a gate, and then crawl on my knee’s to get what I needed.
- It’s much easier to customize the interior of the caravan for my personal needs given its frame structure vs. a smooth glass shell interior.
- I’m having the roof racks made, but not installed. I wanted options open for the future use, and happen to be 6’4”. My roof racks will probably used as a platform for off-the-ground tent camping on top of my truck down in baja when I leave the woman at home and just go with the dogs and another truck. I also figure the roof racks will be good anchor points for a wind-break or awning off the back when boondocking with the truck alone.
Mink has it right when he says you go for what works for you. Just think through all your uses, and go with the best choice. I wouldn’t sweat the money either way. Buy quality and what fits the bill, and you save in the long run… the CTD mentality

.
sarj