Originally posted by dpuckett
Question. Let's say you get your bearings on the carrier, do your preload, and you end up with too much backlash in the R&P, but good contact marks. Do you have to take the bearings off the carrier, and effectively move the bearings over? Taking a shim off one side and putting it on the other? Or does it even make a difference? And what does the average Joe (or Dan :-laf) use to apply the load to the carrier to establish load contact patterns?
If you have too much backlash your pattern should be off, too... . at least, that's what I saw based on my experience. I don't have my FSM handy, but I think the pattern diagrams shown differ based on too much/too little backlash and pinion depth.
The placement of the shims - both pinoin depth and those between the carrier and carrier bearings - will affect the pattern. As far as preload goes, we set up a dial indicator to measure side-to-side movement, then added about . 015" worth of shims over what it took to get the pattern right with the carrier snug. With the extra shims in place, a soft-faced (plastic or leather) mallet was used to get the carrier in place.
Originally posted by dpuckett Also, when I go to a 3. 54 (on my current carrier), will I need to start from scratch? I. E. have to do the preload for the bearings again, and get the offset just so? OR does the 3. 54 ring gear not need to be moved over to match the bigger pinion? Bearings have 40K on them now, so I'll reuse them.
You will need to set the pinion depth and backlash with a new ring and pinion, but if you're reusing the same carrier you can just move the shims side-to-side to get the right pattern.
I'd strongly suggest buying a master kit (new pinion and carrier bearings/races, shims, ring gear bolts, Loctite, marking compound) if you're changing the ring and pinion. Odds are you will damage the shims when removing the carrier bearings (you can measure them and build a new shim pack with new ones in the master kit). Also, make "set up" bearings out of your old parts (hone the inside of the bearings so they slide on and off with minimal effort). Odds are pretty slim that you'll nail the set up on the first try, so the bearings will be coming off at least a couple times. One thing I learned: seat the "set up" bearings well to compress the shims.

I had everything dead on using my set up bearings, but when I pressed the new bearings on I wound up with too much backlash.

Turns out there was a taper on the carrier that kept the shims from sitting flush when putting the bearings on by hand, but pressing them on compressed them several thousandths more.
This all sounds pretty intimidating - I know it was for me

- but once you start doing it things will make more sense. The FSM is an excellent source of info, but most of us don't have all the special tools they call for. We did my axles with only a dial indicator and stand, micrometer, and bearing puller/separator - most of which was bought at Harbor Freight.

Round up all the parts and tools ahead of time, read the FSM a couple times, and then give yourself an extra day or two to get the project done - if it takes longer than anticipated you're covered. If it takes less, then you have time to start breaking in the gears before you start working them.
