I posted the stuff below the line on the thread about the 160, 175, and 215 pumps. It seems that one source of Chris's compalint against Diesel Dynamics concerns a conversation about injection pumps.
Ya know, even a vendor can have a bad day, and after being badgered with questions all day, can get impatient
A properly modified pump, even with all used parts, can deliver more power than a brand new unmodified pump. Which one is worth more depends on the pump's condition, and your goal in life. Sickly's pump has given 609 hp in public (613. 7 in private

). It has over 100,000 miles on it. A brand new 215 hp pump should give about 207 hp on the dyno.
_______________________________________________
>>Cumminsgetme dynoed 446 with his 175 pump and then put on one of Joe's maxed out 215 pumps and put up 476. Not much difference in my opinion for the price tag. <<
There are reasons why adding fuel via larger pump doesn't give the power increase you expect. With a diesel you need compression (and part of that is a good valve job) not just for what it does in a gas engine, but to heat the air and start the burning process. I have seen a loss of 50 hp from a worn out valve job--not one that is totally roached, just worn out after 75,000 miles.
There are some secrets, but I did not hold out on Cord (Cumminsgetme). Bolted onto my engine, it should give 600 hp just like the 913 pump I am using, my original pump with over 100,00 miles on it. All I assumed was that Bosch knows how to balance and calibrate their new pumps. As Cord does more stuff he should get more power out of that pump. As someone else noted, the fuel is only one part. You need to get that part sorted out, but then go on to other things.
From the other thread I see that Chris is down on DD. Well, they feel (rightly I think) that just because someone can ask a question does not mean the answer must be given. No one can doubt that their stuff works, because they have the dyno results. Similarly, the projects Lawrence and I have collaborated on were effective. Just check with the Ford guys who put on the Dyno Day last March when Sickly got 609. 3 and 609. 5 hp on #2 diesel fuel only.
Different trucks act differently, and it is easy to lose some hp when the air is bad, if all of it has to come through the turbo (no nitrous). Other stuff can be a problem too, and that is why Lawrence at Diesel Dynamics uses the dyno extensively to verify the power increases his customers pay for. Some other vendors also verify their products this way. BD Power and TST Products come to mind as two other shops that have in-house dynos.
In summary, I think it is fair for a customer to expect the promised power gains, or if no specific amount of power gain is promised, the product is what was advertised. As you get away from simple add-ons, it gets harder to predict the power gain exactly because other variables come into play and are not in the vendor's control. It is another thing to pursue the exact approach, adjustment specs, and parts relentlessly. It is yet another thing when someone uses one shop for advice, and then buys elsewhere, where there is little or no help available, because the price is slightly better.
Cost cutting has become a way of life, and is not all bad. It works with generic, standardized products and services. It doesn't work well with situations where expertise is critical, whether diesel power or building a bathroom correctly. If you are in construction, you know the difference between sheet rock, greenboard, and the "hardiback" board. You know if the worker doesn't add latex milk to the grout, you will have loose tiles later. The final product looks the same, but doesn't last the same.
Chris expects the answer to what parts are different in the three Dodge P7100 pumps. Your Bosch shop can show you their catalog. A very large number of parts have different part numbers across the three pumps. That is your answer. Sorry, that is all the Bosch factory tells their shops. Bosch expects the shop to order the correct bfactory part for the part number of pump they are repairing. Which parts work best? Which different parts have significant differences? You only find that out by trial and error; Bosch doesn't say. Someone has to spend a lot of time and money trying parts and by looking at parts inferring which ones are likely to improve fuel delivery. Who will pay the shop to do this? Why should those answers be free to everyone, customer and competitor alike?
Sorry to bore those who don't need this ranting. I just felt this thread and a few others needed some clarification as to why vendors keep information to themselves, and why I feel it benefits all of us. Without competitive advantage, the good shops can't stay in business. They can't do R&D while giving the cheapest price. they try instead to give the best value to their loyal customers. On the companion DD thread, a number of their customers responded favorably. It seems they ARE getting good value.