I had WT when I first bought the truck...they didn't hold up well and were poorly designed with alot of round indents that trapped dirt and were hard to clean...went with another brand the didn't last either, went back to WT, much better design and thicker rubber... 4 years into the now and they still look greatI've had the Weathertech thick pliable rubber mats in both of my Rams. They're like new and have been in since late '06. In retrospect however,I wish I'd opted for liners as they protect more area.
I use rugged ridge and really like them. They fit well. I’ve had em in my last three trucks and they’ve done really good. I scrub em when I wash the truck and they continue to look like new.