Truckie,
Don't fret, your lift pump is bad, dude! Period! There's 4 part #'s for new lift pumps and only one # is going to be a good one. If you want to know the 'good' one, log onto "Cumminsstuff.com", or
Cummins parts store also has the acceptable #. , with the added pigtail.
I had the same exact problem as you, and even the _ealer admitted that there's a problem with several lift pump part #'s.
I do not know about the _ealer, but I do have experience with Cummins and they have the correct part #!
Bob in Sacramento