Originally posted by Briar Hopper
From a mechanic's viewpoint, the American V-Twin bikes are highly desireable, due to the parts interchangeability, and versatility. No other type of bike has the huge amount of aftermarket customizing choices. It's kind of like another favorite choice of mechanics and custom builders, the Chevrolet/GM small-block V-8.
The rice rockets serve their purpose, but they have no soul. A Harley does.
I suspect a lot of the people who have to pay others to work on their vehicles are also the type to turn up their nose at Harleys. That's good , for several reasons. More to go around for those of us who appreciate them.
It's the old phrase, "If I have to explain, you wouldn't understand". I know people who actually don't understand the point behind getting a jeep and going rock-crawling, or getting a race car.
Deep down, the truly hardcore or old school types, the mechanically inclined, the gearheads, they understand the need.
As someone who does all his own work (and LIKES IT), I have to disagree with your generalization. After all, "all generalizations are false", right?
I can see the merit of simple design, and indeed it's one of the things that makes the Cummins a pretty good design.
Your parallel to the SBC is pretty close. The pushrod V-8 isn't cutting edge tech, but it's proven and it works. Some people want this in a bike also.
But even the venerable SBC has been updated. THe current generation of V-8s are amazingly refined.
But the truth is that there's a design limitation, and technology has moved on.
I wish I knew what it was about America that makes us slow to embrace new technology. Exhibit A: NASCAR.
NASCAR is one of those things that should be considered like horse racing and the America's cup: a race based on an outdated technology that we have fallen in love with.
But what makes NASCAR so pointless is that they put so many rules on those cars that there's NO ingenuity whatsoever. I thought the point of racing was to be faster than the other guy?
The truth is, that America has already built sophisticated engines. How about 400hp/liter (that would be roughly 2400hp in a CTD)- NATURALLY ASPIRATED? It was achieved by a two-stroke engine built in Texas.
Oddly enough, it didn't use pushrods.
The Japanese are making literbikes that produce 150 hp! This is more power than the typical 2. 0L engine in a small car, which has TWICE the displacement!!
Why aren't turbos more popular? Why no diesel-electric hybrid cars getting 80mpg? Why only compression ratios in the 9's instead of the 13s-- the technology has been proven and the mpg was much improved!
I digress. The point is that Harleys have only become more refined (and even then, very slowly) because SOME of their customers demanded it.
There are a large population of Harley riders that would pay $20K for a new KnuckleHead, even though the tech is sorely outdated.
With customers like Harley has (who will often buy one no matter how bad one is or how much better something else is), what incentive does the company have to compete??
Why should Ford build a better 6. 0 Powerstroke when thousands upon thousands line up to buy one in spite of the reputation?
As a Capitalist, I want the better guy to win. It really irritates me when I think of the possibility of some guy building a fantastic bike with an ingenious engine and trans, superb handling and rise, and fit & finish worthy of a Rolex, offering it at a great price, and STILL not being able to compete with H-D JUST BECAUSE OF A FRICKING NAME.
Ingenuity should be rewarded. Those who are content to rest on their laurels should be challenged thusly. If it weren't for the American car companies of the 1970's, the Japanese wouldn't have gained such a foothold. Indeed, the "Big three" are now GM, Ford, and TOYOTA! American car makers believed they were kings of the world, pumping out gas-guzzling junk and expecting the public to love it.
I would definitely prefer that the best cars in the world were made in America, and priced reasonably. After all, "made in America" used to mean that the quality was the highest available.
It doesn't always mean that anymore-- too bad.
Justin