The HX35 is not out of it's map at 30 psi at all RPM ranges, my miles driven and pyro numbers prove that it is useful. To say otherwise would be like saying my stock steering shaft will not drive my truck, that I need a Borgeson. I have never run off the road with my lil old stocker shaft
No, the concepts are not comparable. I never even suggested the former. I clearly stated the HX35 will produce air to 30 psi and a bit more and at that point it is beyond its compressor map. Did NOT say it would not do it. Did NOT say it would not work. Even an H1C will boost to 30 psi and work, done it more times than I can count. Same with an HX35, and HE351, and HE351VE, and modified HX35, etc, etc.
I clearly said it is out of its map at that point, I made NO assumptions on its effectiveness. The general discussion around compressor maps has some inherent parameters that are taken for granted. Specifically, saying a turbo is out of its compressor map means it has exceed the point where it has been determined to be most effiicient. ANY compressor will have a map that is essentially infinite, however, you will not be able to see data points on the high\low side because because they will be so close together as to be indistinguishable.
If you don't like the nomeclature lets change it to "At 30 psi a stock HX35 is out of its compressor efficiency map.". This statement in no way makes assumptions about the
functionalcompressor map on a specific CPL. As I told the OP, raise the boost and see if it will work for the conditions. There is no way to say definitely it will work, only that the chances are good it will.
The real question for the OP is does he want to use what he has or something better, he has to answer that. The truth is a larger turbo will make the same air at 20 psi as the HX35 will make 30 psi, and, last a lot longer doing it while providing overhead for future changes.