Hey, Matt,
How about a '36 Hudson Terraplane 2-Door Sedan with factory suicide doors and the long fold-in-the-middle hood with a small I-6 or V6 with the automatic transmission? I bought the 'Plane back in November and it's all disassembled right now and still in the planning stage. Like you, I don't want the same old stuff you see everywhere. I do want something I can enjoy and drive any time I want. Don't want all the chrome engine parts - those things don't make it run any better.
I am considering something like a Dakota or S-10 or Ranger V6 & automatic & rear end. Maybe the whole chassis if everything measures out just right. Then I'd have the new(er) brakes and suspension. Probably some adapting, but since the body on my 'Plane is outstanding (other than the front floor area) so I don't want to have to cut it to make it fit.
Going to be a fun project.
Wayne