For those who say "don't ever lease" ... I say that you are not being open minded. For some, a lease is one way of getting into a vehicle without thowing good money after bad (so long as said vehicle keeps its value- such as a CTD. )
That being said, here is my experience:
I leased my 2001. 5- I did my home work and at the time the monthy payments were all I could afford as opposed to a purchase agreement. A lease allows one to get more vehicle upfront with the advantage of not paying full sales tax (the latter is pay- as- you- go. ) I knew my buyout at the end ($12,700) ... but also knew the relative sale value at the end... which was around $20,000 (with 65K miles. ) The relative comparison is only valid when milage is taken into account. If one plans to drive MANY miles and one can make momthly PURCHASE payment, then this is the way to go.
If yearly average miles driven are reasonable (i. e 12-15K) AND you plan to trade up (or sell) than a lease is a viable option (again... only if the vehicle KEEPS its percieved value. )
I was not able to negotiate down a lease (the terms are spelled out so why would a lending institution take less than agreed terms- especially if the end value is more than the buy- out?)
With a value kept vehicle such as my 2001, I actually built up equity via the lease but it would only be realised by either buying it out or trading. 20K- 12. 7 = $7,300 (approx. ) I could have always turned it in (and paid milage penalty) or at the least buy it for the AGREED purche end lease term and sell it and walk away with cash... or... use the equity towards a new truck.
I did the latter... my payments are only $20 more per month for a new 2005 over what a buy- out loan would cost. And the new one IS a purchase. When I tallied up a lease vs. loan it cost about $1500 more. But, for my budget at the time it was all I could afford and was not chasing shadows with my money... . And I was driving the truck I wanted. Any other vehicle BOUGHT with the same money would not have returned me the money I vested. (imagine a purchase of a gasser with the same monthly payment as a lease! imagine it after 5 years and think of what I would have as far as trade value for a new one!... not as much as with a CTD!)
Bottom line... I have never heard of 'negotiating down' a buy- out agreement. Use the end terms to you advantage, do your homework, know what you want to do and work it to your advantage.
JMO
-frank.