biggieou said:
reliable as everyone hypes them up to be.
Unfortunately, perception is reality. That perception is killing the US market.
But there are other factors in the car market. Looking at things completely objectively, if you want a small economy car for commuter use what are your choices:
-Corolla
-Civic
-Altima
-Cobalt
-Focus
-Neon
Now, if you go and look at each one of these vehicles and pay attention only to material qualities, fit/finish, fuel economy, noise, vibration, and harshness, you'd be hard pressed not to choose the Civic (or perhaps Corolla). From an objective standpoint, it does it's job (that is, being a small commuter car) extremely well, without fanfair, with decent styling, and with tolerable comfort. Does anyone think a Cobalt or Neon or Focus is a better small car than the Civic? I've driven all four, and the Civic outclassed them all in terms of NVH and fit/finish - factors that have little to do with actual reliability, and everything to do with perception. As I said at the beginning, perception is reality. If car A is 10 times more reliable than car B, but car A "looks cheap" inside, people are going to "percieve" that it's actually less reliable than car B. Furthermore, they'll actually go to great lengths to convince themselves that car B is more reliable, usually by ignoring all factual evidence and relying on hearsay.
Trucks are a different story, which is why "car people" buy Tundras and Titans, but "truck people" buy domestics. Domestic trucks are heavier built, and probably offer fewer compromises in terms of strength. They're also marketed more appropriately to the US consumer (which is a huge factor... maybe the biggest) than the Asian brand trucks are. But the Asians getting better. The latest Tacoma and Tundra commercials are pretty good.
As far as I'm concerned, there is not a significant difference between the domestics and the Asians in terms of reliability anymore (averaged across all model lines per manufacturer). There remain significant differences in appearance and the resultant perception of quality/reliability, however.
-Ryan