YUP - even the OEM paper filters will often bypass dirt past poorly fitting seals - here's the low-mileage one off my '02 back when I pulled it to switch to a K&N oiled type:
#ad
BUT, lots of guys seem willing to ignore or overlook leakage as seen above in the tan-looking material deposited upon the seal - but will scream bloody murder if a K&N type does it! I got the absolute best oil analysis ever, on a number of oil analysis reports, while using my own K&N drop-in filter - but WAS careful to also use the K&N sealing grease along with it...
Eventually, power add-ons required better airflow than I felt the K&N could efficiently deliver, so went to this:
#ad
Just be sure to use the properly rated filters for the job at hand - and install and maintain them properly, they are the life of your engine!
I like to put a light grease layer on both the top and bottom of the air filter box where the rubber filter gasket sits... the grease helps the box lid slide into position AND helps to catch any dust that might result from an improperly fitted or pinched air filter. Alternatively, you can put the grease on all 3 edges of the air filter gasket (where the dust is in Garys picture). An old mechanic freind of mine taught me this trick.