Tim said:
The stock wheels are forged aluminum like your Welds. There is no way an OEM would use a cast aluminum wheel on a heavy duty pickup... . way too much liability.
Tim, with regard to your reference to vehicle manufacturers and cast aluminum wheels, Eagle cast aluminum wheels meet US DOT standards just like the forged. The OEM load rating of the basic steel wheels Dodge puts on their 3/4 and 1 ton trucks is 2600lbs.
Specifically, for my truck the gross axle weight rating or GAWR works out 5200/6150 lbs (front/rear). To get the load rating I felt was necessary for a new wheel for my axles I took the larger of those two numbers, in this case 6150, and divide by 2... 3075 lbs. BTW - Dodge actually takes the lower of those two.
It is my understanding that Weld uses semi-solid forging when producing their wheels and Eagle uses high counter pressure cast molding to manufacture theirs.
The measured load ratings on the Cheyenne Welds is 4,000 lbs. The Eagle Alloy 114s have a measured load rating of 3,420 lbs. Thus, in this case the major difference in forging vs casting production method works out to 580lbs a wheel. There is no question the Welds are stronger, but I didn't see a need for the additional load strength given the max load of the axles and the tires.
Next I looked at price... and it basically worked out to I could buy ONE Weld for the price I paid for all FOUR Eagles.
Tim said:
I wouldn't either... and if I did, after my past experience with Eagle, I wouldn't use an Eagle.
Not sure what your experience with Eagle is/was but I preferred the look of the Eagle 114s to the Weld Cheyennes. I also appreciated the fact that Eagle is made in the USA something which was not specified anywhere on Weld's website.