Gosh, it's good to post a suggestion for once, instead of a question!!
I just installed a Mag-Hytec last week, and there is no freakin' way that the O ring supplied would have sealed the diff cover, because of the way the diff cover was off center. Mag-Hytec suggests a good test to verify whether the O ring will seal, so have some silicone handy in case it won't. I tow occasionally, but I really like the ease of servicing the diff now with the drain plug. For what it's worth, mine took 5 quarts of oil and 8 oz. of friction modifier.
If you are going to change it to solve the leak, but won't be adding the Mag-Hytec for a while, I wouldn't fill it with synthetic as you'll just lose it when you add the Mag-Hytec.
I put Super Tech from Walmart in for a week until I got home and was able to get synthetic. I replaced the conventional with Red Line 75w-140, and I swear the truck runs smoother

2 others have agreed with me, and it seems my mileage is going to be somewhat higher since doing so. Haven't run a full tank yet, but got 227. 8 miles on the first quarter tank-usually around 196
