"Why Gun Rights Advocates Oppose Gun Registration"
Excerpt from
Gun Registration and Gun Control
by Bartholomew Roberts
GunCite - Gun Control: gun registration;firearm registration
A centralized registration system is the one usually proposed by gun control activists, and it is the type most feared by gun rights advocates. At the heart of resistance to registration is the belief that it encourages firearm prohibitions and ultimately leads to confiscation. (It is also why many choose not to comply and register weapons already owned. )
Those who favor more gun control often accuse gun owners of being paranoid, but the track record of firearms registration is not a good one.
The poor record of gun control and registration in countries without democratic traditions is discussed in these two sources and will not be elaborated upon here:
Of Holocausts and Gun Control, Washington University Law Quarterly, 1997.
Book review of Lethal Laws, N. Y. Law School J. Int'l & Comp. L. , 1995.
Democratic societies have also used registration to confiscate what were once previously legally-owned firearms. Many gun rights advocates "believe that a nucleus of anti-gun activists will agitate for restrictions and bans on the 'most dangerous' type of firearm in common use. When that gun is banned they will move on to the next model which will in turn become the 'most dangerous' type. Firearms owners fears are supported by what has happened recently in the UK, Australia, and Canada, and has previously happened in NZ [New Zealand]. " (
The Registration of Firearms: A Compendium of Available Fact From Australia, Canada, and New Zealand, 1998)
Gun Confiscation in Democratic Societies
New Zealand has had some form of firearms registration since 1921. In 1974, all revolvers lawfully held for personal security were confiscated. (Same source as previous paragraph)
In May of 1995, Canada's Bill C-68 prohibited previously legal and registered small-caliber handguns. Current owners of such guns were "grandfathered," which means the guns are to be forfeited upon death of the owner. Bill C-68 also authorizes the Canadian government to enact future weapons prohibitions.
On 10 May 1996, Australia banned most semi-automatic rifles and semi-automatic and pump shotguns. Prior to this law, many Australian states and territories had firearms registration. Owners of these newly outlawed firearms were required to surrender them (with some monetary compensation). All such firearms are to be confiscated and destroyed after a 12-month amnesty program. Roughly 600,000 of an estimated 4 million Australian guns have been surrendered to authorities and destroyed.
"Since 1921, all lawfully-owned handguns in Great Britain are registered with the government, so handgun owners have little choice but to surrender their guns in exchange for payment according to government schedule... The handgun ban by no means has satiated the anti-gun appetite in Great Britain. (
All the Way Down the Slippery Slope: Gun Prohibition in England and Some Lessons for Civil Liberties in America, Hamline Law Review, 1999)
Even in the United States, registration has been used to outlaw and confiscate firearms. In New York City, a registration system enacted in 1967 for long guns, was used in the early 1990s to confiscate lawfully owned semiautomatic rifles and shotguns. (Same source as previous paragraph) The New York City Council banned firearms that had been classified by the city as "assault weapons. " This was done despite the testimony of Police Commissioner Lee Brown that no registered "assault weapon" had been used in a violent crime in the city. The 2,340 New Yorkers who had registered their firearms were notified that these firearms had to be surrendered, rendered inoperable, or taken out of the city. (NRA/ILA Fact Sheet:
Firearms Registration: New York City's Lesson)
More recently, California revoked a grace period for the registration of certain rifles (SKS Sporters) and declared that any such weapons registered during that period were illegal. (California Penal Code, Chapter 2. 3,
Roberti-Ross Assault Weapons Control Act of 1989 section 12281(f) ) In addition, California has prohibited certain semi-automatic long-rifles and pistols. Those guns currently owned, must be registered, and upon the death of the owner, either surrendered or moved out of state. (FAQ #13 from the California DOJ Firearms Division Page).
-------------------------
To sum it up: just because you're paranoid doesn't mean they aren't trying to outlaw your guns.
What are your questions?