Here I am

Engine/Transmission (1998.5 - 2002) The importance of using a paper air filter

Attention: TDR Forum Junkies
To the point: Click this link and check out the Front Page News story(ies) where we are tracking the introduction of the 2025 Ram HD trucks.

Thanks, TDR Staff

Engine/Transmission (1994 - 1998) Merry christmas!!!

Status
Not open for further replies.
The Importance of Using a Paper Air Filter
(cut and paste from latest Cummins "Turbo Diesel News")

Maintaining a clean air filter is very important for the life of your engine. What does dust do to an engine? Let’s follow the air as it enters the intake. First, the turbo gets hit with the dust – the blades are spinning as fast as 150,000 rpm, and hitting just a small amount of dust at that speed can actually remove material from the turbo blades. Next, the piston rings and engine bore take a beating because the dust acts as an abrasive material, wearing away those two sliding surfaces. Dust can then find its way into the oil by getting past the rings against the bores of the engine. With the oil filter able to hold only so much dirt before plugging and then bypassing, eventually the rest of the engine bearings suffer.

The factory-pleated paper air filter is a critical element of the air system, and it ensures that clean air is delivered to the engine to be used during the combustion process. It is designed to balance both the flow across the filter and filtered surface area, to ensure that your engine runs at peak performance. For example, a driver who uses a particularly dusty route may have 100g of dirt ingested into his air filter. The factory filter at 99. 9 percent efficiency will have allowed 0. 1g of dirt through the filter and into the engine. An aftermarket cotton-gauze filter or oiled cotton-gauze filter on the other hand typically runs around 97 percent efficient. That 3 percent difference can have a big effect on the life of your engine.

At 97 percent efficiency, 3g equal 30 times more dirt sent through to the engine! This multiplication is true for the life of the filter – the oiled cotton-gauze filter will always let 30 times more dirt through.
Now, let’s compare and contrast your factory pleated paper air filter with some common aftermarket filters.
While cotton-gauze-style filters have a lower restriction when they are clean, there are two fundamental issues with them, the first being dust-holding capacity. Due to the thickness of the material used, these filters have very low dust-holding capacity. The way in which they hold the dust means they plug up quickly, and just a small amount of dust makes the restriction increase substantially.

However, the biggest issue with cotton-gauze filters is their filtration efficiency. As mentioned earlier, restriction is based on a combination of the filtration level and the surface area. The surface area of aftermarket filters is typically much smaller than that of the standard filters, so they manage to offer lower restriction on a clean filter by having much bigger gaps in the material, leading to much lower filtration efficiency.

Oiled cotton-gauze filters are generally cleaned and re-oiled at certain mileage intervals. However, the oil used in these filters is hard on the mass air flow (MAF) sensor and surrounding components. The oil tends to come off these filters as a fine mist and coat the intake systems. This leads to incorrect readings from the already-sensitive MAF sensor.

While all diesel engines are vulnerable to dust, using the recommended factory pleated paper air filter does the best job protecting your engine while balancing flow and restriction. The paper material leads to higher filtration efficiency, which will ultimately lead to a cleaner, stronger Cummins Turbo Diesel.
 
I have to agree with this Harvey, more than 35 years ago AMZOIL came out with a "cleanable/reoilable" filter and I know some farmers in Idaho who lost engines because of this issue and I never was pulled into this type of filter and have always used paper and changed it when necessary!! This is CHEAP at any price!!! I think that 5 or 6 years ago there was a series of posts in TDR addressint some of the cleanable and oilable sfilters on the market and comparing airflow and looking at the particles getting thru the cleanable filters. This was good reading and it confirmed what has again said!



gtwitch in wyoming
 
Yep, my friend who was formerly a Dodge dealer mechanic agrees with us also. He has told me the sad stories. The thing that is hard for me to understand is the fact that the OEM fleetguard filter is completely satisfactory until hp levels exceed about 450 hp so there is zero gain to be had from the screen door filters some love to install.
 
I worked for a pleated paper filter manufacturer many years ago and my job was to test the performance of the filters. Everything in Harvey's post exactly matches the results we got in the filter lab. Pleated paper filters are the highest efficiency by far and are the best balance between dirt holding capacity and restriction rise of the element over time.
 
Currently using an AFE Stage II with Pro-Guard cotton media. I once saw advertised a paper filter replacement but can't find it. Do ya'all have any leads on where I can locate a paper replacement?
Thx, Joe
 
I agree with Harvey - what he states is exactly the truth. I work for a major OEM and my brother was an engineering manager for a larger filter company that provided filters to us - same story - it is very hard to beat a paper element air filter. I spent 4 years working in the middle east and at times we had machines running in the desert where sandstorms filled the air and plugged filters - I am glad we were not running anything besides paper.
 
Many tractors have cylinder shaped air filters. The larger outer is paper, the smaller inner is a cotton. You clean your outer as much as you want but as soon as the inner shows any dirt at all its time to replace both. To me this is the best system having the large surface area for flow and a back up filter to compensate for neglect. Ive wondered why no oem or aftermarket companies offer a filter system with the same concept for trucks. None that I have seen anyways.
 
I agree with the paper filter thing too. For those wanting a CFM upgrade over stock the only thing I know of is the BHAF. Most BHAFs flow 590 CFM at 6" H2O restriction, a stock 3rd Gen airbox is around 500 CFM at 6" which doesn't give you a major improvement, but every bit helps.



BHAFs with 590 CFM:

Fleetguard AH19037

Donaldson: B105006

Wix: 42790

Napa: 2790

Carquest: 87790



Not quite as good:

Hastings AF1012 565 cfm



Do not get

Fleetguard AH19002 only 400 cfm
 
I got tired of my BHAF extra engine noise while towing a few years ago and put the filter box back in with paper filter with addition holes in the bottom near the finder and no boot to the finder. Left the heat shield on the turbo also.

Other than the reduced noise, I can not tell the difference!

When I bought my truck in 2001 the dealer sold me a KN filter for it???? I run that for a couple years, until they started warning about them. In the NW that is probably not as bad as in a dusty area of the country.

SNOKING
 
Yeah, in Washington state you have fresh clean air blowing in off the Pacific so you can probably get away with it indefinitely if you want to run the K&N. In my area it is guaranteed fatal for a Cummins engine.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top