I've had a BD Turboguard installed on my truck for 6 months. I took it off last week (thanks for the parts, TWest!).
It only works when letting off the throttle, so on-throttle shift-induced barks will not be eliminated. If you're on the throttle and back off, it will blow off once set up properly.
A few things about it- It's an analog control setup, so you have to spend a significant amount of time dialing in all the settings for it to work properly. Additionally you have to spend some time playing with shims and springs in the valve itself so your turbo doesn't bark even when the valve is working.
I have several reasons for taking mine off-
1. When drag racing or hauling arse on the street I'd have to disconnect it, as it would blow off between shifts and never re-seat. This created a boost leak and extreme EGTS. I'd have to cycle the throttle (which cycles the valve) 4 or 5 times after to get the valve to re-seat and seal.
2. I don't think the Tial BOV is designed to work with the pressures created by our diesel trucks. My first Tial BOV went south on the way to a drag race. Getting on the freeway behind a 12v dually, I shifted and then there was a massive boost leak. It turns out the o-ring that seals the valve had blown out. Not the viton o-ring between the intake tube and the valve, but the seal portion of the valve itself. It got jammed in the opening leaving the entire valve open about 3mm. I believe the force of 55psi of air exiting the valve causes the o-ring to blow out of it's seat.
BD send me a new Tial BOV, but it only took 1 week for the o-ring to blow out of that one too. This was the main reason for me pulling the valve.
3. When set to blow off and not bark my turbo, it would vent the air down to about 3psi in the manifold. With a laggy SPS66, it would really suck to wait for boost to build between every shift. I would lose a lot of time and make lots of smoke when trying to drive quickly. If I used a larger spring to keep the manifold pressure to about 10-12psi on shifts, the turbo would bark even if the valve opened. Frustrating to say the least.
Anyway, I pulled the valve last week, and I've learned to drive around the SPS66 so it does not bark. What a difference! I like driving the truck a lot more now. Between taking off the BOV, installing a Smarty, and this weekend a SPS62 my truck should be very responsive around town. I can't wait!
Summary-
If you have a manual trans, don't get one. If you have an auto and want to protect your turbo when you back off the throttle, go ahead and do it. At least with an auto you won't have a boost leak (if any) until your race is over.
Perhaps others have had better experiences, but this is mine. I'm sending everything back to BD so they can evaluate and give me some advice. I'm willing to re-install if they diagnose the problem.